Apparently I have a problem.
My problem is that I don't have a problem with our daughter liking princesses.
I know, I know. I should. What self-respecting, educated, liberated, enlightened, liberal woman would be okay with it in this day and age? At least, that is, according to all the learned lifelong scorn and ever accumulating, adamant anti-princess parenting articles I'm seeing these days. Clearly we're doing our daughter some grievous harm. A lifelong disservice to her self esteem and intelligence. It's only a matter of time before our little ticking time bomb of frilly, glittered, dancing crinoline grows up into a weak, vapid, co-dependent, shrill caricature. Or not.
For the record, I never in my life thought I would have a daughter that loved pink, purple, princesses and sparkles. It honestly never crossed my mind. Because I never did like any of those things myself. I have zero experience with all of this. Baby dolls and princesses were not my thing. The rationale for the love of pink has eluded me my whole life. I just didn't get it. In fact, the color pink outright disgusted me between the ages of 4 to 20-something. I loathed it. For no apparent rational reason except it really wasn't my favorite color and I felt honor bound to hate it. And that was all me. It certainly didn't come from my parents. My dad could not have cared less, I'm sure. My mom actually decorated my sister's and my room in pink. A lot of it. Which, I pissed and moaned about constantly (poor mom, she was so proud of the decorating she did). She would have gladly given me dolls, but I never wanted any. With the exception of Baby Alive. And then I wanted one only because they ate and pooped and I thought that was awesome. I actually cared more about my stuffed animals, getting a bike, HotWheels, roller skates, baseball and running with the boys. I wanted to go around with no shirt on and was devastated that I couldn't have some of those cool Underoos like the boys. I wanted nothing to do with skirts or dresses. Very much to my mother's dismay, I'm sure. But, that was who I was. And as I've learned extensively over the last 3+ years, this isn't about me.
This is all about our wonderfully girly and sparkly Princess Zoƫ. Three years and hundreds of well-meaning unisex colored, genderless outfits and neutral room colors down the road...it didn't stick. Early into her second year on this earth she made it clear her favorite colors were purple and pink. She said so. Gotta love the early verbal skills. Walking was for chumps, she needed to communicate. And that she has.
In the beginning all this princess stuff started to worry me. I should be intervening, I thought. Maybe she should know no Disney whatsoever and instead we should bombard her with images of strong positive women role models from history, and shouldn't we be making more trips to the Children's Museum and, and... I should be shunning those sparkly, doe-eyed, vacuous and ridiculously unrealistic little song birds at every corner. Beating them down like a Whack-A-Mole game! But, I don't.
Why?
It just goes contrary to what my gut and my brain are telling me. Both of them are countering me with, "chill, woman, what's the big deal?". She is just responding to (and not from commercials) and showing interest in something that she likes. Like I did, except my early interests was a lot of 'boy stuff'. Which was met with a LOT of crappy commentary, like "tomboy" and picking on, and way too much overanalyzing of my perceived sexuality and a multitude of hurt feelings for me on the receiving end of all this chatter about me. Which, by the way, I was present for and digesting all of that. So don't talk crap to me about anti-princesses in front of my kid. I will not, ever, tell my daughter or in any way intimate to my daughter that her liking something I don't, or what folks find silly or whatever else, makes her disappointing, silly, wrong, or less than...anything. She is who she is, she likes what she likes and I love her for her (we both do). Just like we try to give her a balanced diet when it comes to food, we do the same with toys and media. We're not perfect by any stretch, but I think she's doing alright and so are we. All of our early intervention with media (and fashion) control has not stopped her from being drawn to what she likes. And some of that is princesses. And I'm perfectly happy to accommodate that. Besides, she's three. Tomorrow she could wake up and decide she'd rather watch a movie about trains. After all, she loves trains too. And planes, and fish, and ice cream, and the beach, and cats and her bike and dancing and drawing and playing computer games. She has a lot of interests. The only one of those interests that seems to make people freak out is the princess stuff. Why?
If our girls are going to be fed a daily diet of you can do and be anything you want to be, then why does that phrase carry an asterisk for our girls in the 2010's? We control -or like to think that we do- so much about our kids' environment. We go on and on about empowering them, which is great, but then we have to control everything? Even when they're playing pretend? Isn't part of empowerment becoming confident? If I tell her she can do or be anything, "except ____". What is that doing? Besides shoving my own agenda down my kid's throat. It seems to me I would be telling her that there was something wrong with her liking or wanting to do something that she's interested in. That, to me, seems counterintuitive to the whole underlying purpose of bringing up strong and confident kids. If we're supposed to be OK with our boys wanting to dress up in the princess costume if he wants to, then why are we on the other hand supposed to be telling our girls no, they shouldn't want to do that? It's confusing to me, I can only imagine how confusing it would be for a young child.
Screw that. Of course I will do everything in my power to ensure that she is a strong, independent thinking, self assured, confident young woman (as will her dad). I would have it no other way. The only limitations on her capabilities will be determined by her inherent potential, her own will and life choices. Not whether or not she was into princesses as a child.
I watched a crapload of Bugs Bunny, Tom and Jerry and Road Runner growing up. Actually, a LOT of TV, in general, growing up. Including commercials. I never wrapped somebody's hair up in dynamite rollers on a lark, I don't spend my time on Amazon looking for Acme Anvils, and while the 'Where's the Beef' commercials were funny, it didn't turn me into a 24/7 fast-food addict.
So we have happily wrapped her new big girl bed up in her brand new princess sheets, and let her watch her favorite princess movie over again for the third day in a row. And before bed we play with the eco/child-friendly wooden castle complete with princesses and king, and talk about why Rapunzel calls Flynn by the name Eugene instead of Flynn. As she lays there drifting in thought before dozing off she also talks to me about dreams, and Winnie the Pooh and Piglet living far away. She tells me, "Hey Mommy, you know what? ... I think Hundred Acre Wood is far away". Yes, she's right, I tell her, but sometimes when you dream about something you can bring it to you. So maybe if she thinks about Pooh and his friends before going to sleep, she'll dream about them, and get to visit them in Hundred Acre Wood. "Yeah!", she whispered excitedly, and promptly rolled over with her eyes squeezed shut.
I think we're doing alright.
My problem is that I don't have a problem with our daughter liking princesses.
I know, I know. I should. What self-respecting, educated, liberated, enlightened, liberal woman would be okay with it in this day and age? At least, that is, according to all the learned lifelong scorn and ever accumulating, adamant anti-princess parenting articles I'm seeing these days. Clearly we're doing our daughter some grievous harm. A lifelong disservice to her self esteem and intelligence. It's only a matter of time before our little ticking time bomb of frilly, glittered, dancing crinoline grows up into a weak, vapid, co-dependent, shrill caricature. Or not.
For the record, I never in my life thought I would have a daughter that loved pink, purple, princesses and sparkles. It honestly never crossed my mind. Because I never did like any of those things myself. I have zero experience with all of this. Baby dolls and princesses were not my thing. The rationale for the love of pink has eluded me my whole life. I just didn't get it. In fact, the color pink outright disgusted me between the ages of 4 to 20-something. I loathed it. For no apparent rational reason except it really wasn't my favorite color and I felt honor bound to hate it. And that was all me. It certainly didn't come from my parents. My dad could not have cared less, I'm sure. My mom actually decorated my sister's and my room in pink. A lot of it. Which, I pissed and moaned about constantly (poor mom, she was so proud of the decorating she did). She would have gladly given me dolls, but I never wanted any. With the exception of Baby Alive. And then I wanted one only because they ate and pooped and I thought that was awesome. I actually cared more about my stuffed animals, getting a bike, HotWheels, roller skates, baseball and running with the boys. I wanted to go around with no shirt on and was devastated that I couldn't have some of those cool Underoos like the boys. I wanted nothing to do with skirts or dresses. Very much to my mother's dismay, I'm sure. But, that was who I was. And as I've learned extensively over the last 3+ years, this isn't about me.
This is all about our wonderfully girly and sparkly Princess Zoƫ. Three years and hundreds of well-meaning unisex colored, genderless outfits and neutral room colors down the road...it didn't stick. Early into her second year on this earth she made it clear her favorite colors were purple and pink. She said so. Gotta love the early verbal skills. Walking was for chumps, she needed to communicate. And that she has.
In the beginning all this princess stuff started to worry me. I should be intervening, I thought. Maybe she should know no Disney whatsoever and instead we should bombard her with images of strong positive women role models from history, and shouldn't we be making more trips to the Children's Museum and, and... I should be shunning those sparkly, doe-eyed, vacuous and ridiculously unrealistic little song birds at every corner. Beating them down like a Whack-A-Mole game! But, I don't.
Why?
It just goes contrary to what my gut and my brain are telling me. Both of them are countering me with, "chill, woman, what's the big deal?". She is just responding to (and not from commercials) and showing interest in something that she likes. Like I did, except my early interests was a lot of 'boy stuff'. Which was met with a LOT of crappy commentary, like "tomboy" and picking on, and way too much overanalyzing of my perceived sexuality and a multitude of hurt feelings for me on the receiving end of all this chatter about me. Which, by the way, I was present for and digesting all of that. So don't talk crap to me about anti-princesses in front of my kid. I will not, ever, tell my daughter or in any way intimate to my daughter that her liking something I don't, or what folks find silly or whatever else, makes her disappointing, silly, wrong, or less than...anything. She is who she is, she likes what she likes and I love her for her (we both do). Just like we try to give her a balanced diet when it comes to food, we do the same with toys and media. We're not perfect by any stretch, but I think she's doing alright and so are we. All of our early intervention with media (and fashion) control has not stopped her from being drawn to what she likes. And some of that is princesses. And I'm perfectly happy to accommodate that. Besides, she's three. Tomorrow she could wake up and decide she'd rather watch a movie about trains. After all, she loves trains too. And planes, and fish, and ice cream, and the beach, and cats and her bike and dancing and drawing and playing computer games. She has a lot of interests. The only one of those interests that seems to make people freak out is the princess stuff. Why?
If our girls are going to be fed a daily diet of you can do and be anything you want to be, then why does that phrase carry an asterisk for our girls in the 2010's? We control -or like to think that we do- so much about our kids' environment. We go on and on about empowering them, which is great, but then we have to control everything? Even when they're playing pretend? Isn't part of empowerment becoming confident? If I tell her she can do or be anything, "except ____". What is that doing? Besides shoving my own agenda down my kid's throat. It seems to me I would be telling her that there was something wrong with her liking or wanting to do something that she's interested in. That, to me, seems counterintuitive to the whole underlying purpose of bringing up strong and confident kids. If we're supposed to be OK with our boys wanting to dress up in the princess costume if he wants to, then why are we on the other hand supposed to be telling our girls no, they shouldn't want to do that? It's confusing to me, I can only imagine how confusing it would be for a young child.
You can do and be anything!*
*exclusions apply. Mom/ Dad /society have to be OK with it, and absolutely NO Princesses allowed, even just pretend, unless you're a boy, then you go boy, get on with your fabulous self**
**Exceptions for "self-rescuing" princesses, because those are the 'cool' ones
**Exceptions for "self-rescuing" princesses, because those are the 'cool' ones
Screw that. Of course I will do everything in my power to ensure that she is a strong, independent thinking, self assured, confident young woman (as will her dad). I would have it no other way. The only limitations on her capabilities will be determined by her inherent potential, her own will and life choices. Not whether or not she was into princesses as a child.
I watched a crapload of Bugs Bunny, Tom and Jerry and Road Runner growing up. Actually, a LOT of TV, in general, growing up. Including commercials. I never wrapped somebody's hair up in dynamite rollers on a lark, I don't spend my time on Amazon looking for Acme Anvils, and while the 'Where's the Beef' commercials were funny, it didn't turn me into a 24/7 fast-food addict.
So we have happily wrapped her new big girl bed up in her brand new princess sheets, and let her watch her favorite princess movie over again for the third day in a row. And before bed we play with the eco/child-friendly wooden castle complete with princesses and king, and talk about why Rapunzel calls Flynn by the name Eugene instead of Flynn. As she lays there drifting in thought before dozing off she also talks to me about dreams, and Winnie the Pooh and Piglet living far away. She tells me, "Hey Mommy, you know what? ... I think Hundred Acre Wood is far away". Yes, she's right, I tell her, but sometimes when you dream about something you can bring it to you. So maybe if she thinks about Pooh and his friends before going to sleep, she'll dream about them, and get to visit them in Hundred Acre Wood. "Yeah!", she whispered excitedly, and promptly rolled over with her eyes squeezed shut.
I think we're doing alright.
Love this. We haven't pushed our daughter one way or the other but we didn't just outfit her room or buy her Princess themed stuff UNTIL SHE ASKED FOR IT. She wanted a Princess sleeping bag- she has one. She loves Cinderella- she watches it.
ReplyDeleteBut she also loves to garden, play with bugs,and build with blocks. I don't buy her princess or cartoon or disney themed clothes because they just annoy me and she is fine with frilly twirly purple dresses just as much.
I grew up with my dad calling me "Princess". He actually still does. I think he perhaps forgets my real name. But when he called 3M "Princess" she said "I am NOT a Princess. I am a 3M!"
So he started calling her BossyPants. :)
That's awesome! BossyPants, lol! Yeah, much of the actual Disney themed stuff can be pretty repulsive and over the top. We have to edit and compromise on some of it. But it's true, they do love the purple and frilly dresses that look like princess stuff just as much...if not more sometimes.
Delete